Questions and Answers:
I. CAT Questions
1. Ralph knew what he and the other boys did. Ralph admits that what they did to Simon was murder:
"Piggy"
"Uh?"
"That was murder." (LOTF 156)
Ralph feels guilty about these actions and is scared about what to do.
Piggy, on the other hand, doesn't want to admit what happened and instead insists that the whole situation was an accident. In fact, Piggy blames Simon for creeping in the dark alone.
"It was an accident," said Piggy suddenly, "that's what it was. An accident."His voice shrilled again. " Coming in the dark. He was batty. He asked for it." He gesticulated widely again. "It was an accident." (LOTF 157)
This shows that Piggy feels guilty about the situation, but only wants to forget it.
Samneric seemed to know what happened last night, but they can't bear think about that awful moment. They want to bury that memory away and not think about it by denying that they were even at the "feast."
"Yes. We were vey tired," repeated Sam, "so we left early. Was it a good-" (LOTF 158)
Samneric denied that they were even present there last night, so that they woudn't feel guilty about what happened.
2. There are two very large differences between Ralph and Jack's response to Simon's death. Ralph knew what he actually did and felt extremely guilty about it.
"Don't you understand, Piggy? The things we did-" (LOTF 157)
Ralph understands the actions and consequences of what had happened that night. He also seems to be the only one to understand, as well as accept this fact.
Om the contrary, Jack seems to be pleased with what he has done. He believes that it was the beast disguised as Simon, therefore justifying his actions as well as enforcing the Jack's belief in the beast.
"He came-disguised. He may come again even though we gave him the head of our kill to
eat. So watch; and be careful." -Jack (LOTF 160)
Jack feels no regret as he believes it was an act of self-defense, which is justifiable.
Ralph feels remorse and gulit, whereas Jack feels nothing and wants to continue to attack the "beast," if necessary.
3. Jack now has total authority over the boys. He is an unjust and cruel leader, letting the power go to his head. Jack used this power to punish Wilfred for no apparent reason. Jack is now a tyrant as the boys completed his order of punishing Wilfred without knowing why.
" I don't know. He didn't say. He got angry and made us tie Wilfred up. He's been"- he
giggled excitedly-"he's been tied for hours, waiting-" (LOTF 159)
The reader can see that Jack has let the power go to his head, and he has turned into a tyrant.
In addition, Jack has become inhumane and cruel. He forced Wilfred to be tied up for hours. Jack has turned to the human state of being primitive. He is now a savage.
" The chief was sitting there, naked to the waist, his face blocked out in white and red."
(LOTF 160)
Jack is now the chief or tyrant and he has turned into a savage. It's noticeable as Jack wears minimal clothing, a sign of civilization, and he paints his face to disguise himself, allowing him to hunt better.
II. Jack is now the chief. The reader can tell as the author now refers to Jack as "the chief." Also, Jack has the group of boys listening to his every move. Such as when the boys punished Wilfred because Jack said so (LOTF 159).
The night grew darker and colder. The island was no longer the paradise the boys thought it was. Ralph first noticed the dark sensation that this night would soon turn for the worst. The sounds of footsteps haunted Ralph as he knew who to expect. Out of the black forest, Jack and Roger came screaming in a frenzy. The boys frightened scattered to take cover. Jack saw Ralph running and chased after him. Ralph and Jack ferociously punched and kicked each other. Neither willing to surrender. Eric hid in the tree, scared he would also suffer Jack's wrath. Sam, noticing his brother was gone, hid in nearby bushes, waiting for the frenzy to be over. Roger was left to "handle" Piggy. Both fought hard, but Roger was stronger. Piggy cried in pain and begged Roger to stop as he repeatedly kicked him. One kick met Piggy's head, knocking out his consciousness. Roger took his glasses and signaled to Jack that the mission is over. Jack was losing the fight to Ralph. Jack realized this and took off running alongside Roger into under the charcoal-like clouds and cold air. Ralph saw Piggy and ran to help him. The only thing on Ralph's mind was the night when Simon died.